Like-kind
has been broadly defined by the IRS to include ANY kind of real estate
for ANY other kind of real estate. For instance an apartment
building can be traded for a farm or, a mobile home park can be traded
for a warehouse. In this regard real estate is a very special
investment tool because very few other investments can be exchanged
with this flexibility. From a broker’s
stand point, this allows the broker to meet the client’s needs to
change the shape of their real estate investment. The client may
want an investment that is easier to manage. Or, the client may
want an investment that provides better cash flow. Or, the client
may want a property yet to be developed. Use of a 1031 exchange
allows the broker to meet the changing investment needs of the client
while at the same time the client has no present tax liability from the
exchange. It’s a great tool for both the client and the
broker.
Now here is a good rule of thumb for you and your clients to
follow: IF NO TAX LIABILITY IS
TO BE INCURRED THE CLIENT MUST TRADE EQUAL OR GREATER BOTH EQUITY AND
FAIR MARKET VALUE. This means that all cash received from
the relinquished property must be used as down payment on the
replacement property. AND,
the replacement property must be equal or larger in fair market value
to the relinquished property.
1) All of the
investor's capital from the sale of the relinquished property must be
reinvested in the replacement property. This includes all down payment,
capital improvement, principal reduction, and appreciation on the
relinquished property. Any cash received by the investor at the sale of
the relinquished property or at the purchase of the replacement
property will be treated as "cash boot" and taxed. However, cash
received in refinancing arrangements often will not be taxed.
2) Tax basis from the relinquished property is carried forward into the
replacement property. The investor is not allowed to take another
depreciation allowance. Tax basis in the replacement property is
calculated by carrying forward the basis of the relinquished property
and increasing it based on additional cash and mortgage.
3) The investor must exchange for like kind property. Real estate must
be exchanged for real estate, not some other investment.
4) In order to fully defer gain the investor must acquire a replacement
property of equal or greater value to the relinquished property.
Trading down in value will result in recognition of some or all of the
gain.
Conclusion: The only time
you should sell rather than exchange is when you are getting out of
real estate altogether. |